Top 10 Homemade Pizza Ingredients List in 2024

Making your pizza at home is unique. Do you remember the first time you tried? I do. I looked at all the fresh ingredients and felt excited. It was like a new adventure in my kitchen.

Each ingredient was essential. They didn’t just add flavor; they created memories. That first bite was about more than taste. It was about enjoying making pizza at home.

Homemade pizza is great because you can make it how you like. It’s fun for both experts and beginners. You follow a recipe but add your favorite toppings. The best part is when your perfect pizza comes out of the oven.

It’s crispy with cheese that’s melted just right. And did you know 96% of people love the recipe enough to make it again?

Now, let’s talk about the essential ingredients. Each one brings something unique to the recipe. They add depth, texture, and flavor to every slice. These fresh items are vital for making pizza at home.

We’re about to discover the top 10 things you need. They will make your homemade pizza taste as good as from a pizzeria.

1. Fresh Mozzarella

Homemade Pizza Ingredients List - Fresh Mozzarella as Homemade Pizza Ingredient

Fresh mozzarella is the perfect cheese for pizza. It’s known for its great melt and creamy flavor. It’s critical to give the pizza its famous stretch and make it taste amazing.

Why is Fresh Mozzarella Essential?

For a real pizza taste, fresh mozzarella is a must. It’s excellent at melting and adds delicious flavor. Most Margherita pizzas have three key ingredients: San Marzano tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, and basil.

This mix tastes good and gives the pizza its traditional stretch. A Margherita pizza for 3 to 4 people takes just 30 minutes to get ready.

Using top-notch ingredients like fresh mozzarella is very important. Adding just 8 ounces of this cheese can improve your pizza. That’s why it gets such high ratings from cooks, like 4.84 out of 5.

Different Types of Mozzarella:

Trying out different pizza cheeses can be fun. Fresh mozzarella, including mozzarella di bufala or fior di latte, offers various tastes and textures.

These have varying fat levels and creaminess, changing how your pizza turns out. While fresh mozzarella in water is top-notch, low-moisture mozzarella lasts longer and is easier to use.

No matter what type you pick, using high-quality mozzarella in your pizzas will make them a hit. It’s the best cheese for pizza.

2. Tomato Sauce

Homemade Pizza Ingredients List - Tomato Sauce as Homemade Pizza Ingredient

The key to a great pizza is its tomato sauce. With the best ingredients and care, you can make a pizza sauce that’s rich and full of flavor. This will make your pizza unforgettable.

Homemade vs. Store-Bought:

Choosing between making your sauce at home or buying it from the store is often about what you like. By making your sauce, you pick the best ingredients.

And, you make sure it has a robust and rich taste. Store-bought sauces might not have as deep a flavor or may include unhealthy additives.

  • Homemade tomato sauce is fresh and customizable to your taste.
  • Store-bought sauce often contains preservatives and added sugars.
  • Homemade sauce can be stored in the refrigerator for up to 2 weeks or up to 3 months in the freezer.

Recipe for Simple Pizza Sauce:

This easy pizza sauce recipe is perfect for anyone. It doesn’t need cooking and only takes 5 minutes to make!

  • 28 oz can of crushed tomatoes
  • 6 oz can of tomato paste
  • 1-2 tablespoons of dried oregano
  • 2 tablespoons of Italian seasoning
  • ½ teaspoon of garlic powder
  • ½ teaspoon of onion powder
  • ½ tablespoon of garlic salt
  • ¼ teaspoon of freshly ground black pepper
  • 1 teaspoon of sugar

The recipe is vegan as written, making it versatile for various dietary needs. Additionally, it yields enough sauce for two large pizzas or four medium-sized pizzas, and you can easily double or triple the recipe if needed.

Mix all ingredients. This sauce not only makes your pizza taste better. It can also be used with meatballs, eggplant, or chicken parmesan to dip breadsticks in.

NutrientAmount per Serving
Vitamin A330 IU
Vitamin C7.1mg

3. Pepperoni

Homemade Pizza Ingredients List - Pepperoni as Homemade Pizza Ingredient

Pepperoni is a long-time favorite on pizzas. It’s known for its spicy taste with a hint of smokiness. When you pick the proper pepperoni, your pizza can become much tastier and better.

A great pepperoni is critical to a delicious pizza. It’s made from the best meats and goes through a unique process to develop its deep flavor. This type of pepperoni is perfect for pizzas.

  • Choose thinly sliced pieces that can crisp up at the edges for a unique crunch.
  • If you prefer chewier pepperoni, opt for thicker slices.
  • Cut some pepperoni into small pieces to reduce greasiness, and layer it under the cheese with the sauce.

Apart from pepperoni, there are other tasty meats for pizza. Consider trying:

  • Italian Sausage
  • Ham
  • Bacon
  • Chicken

These meats bring different flavors and textures. They make pizzas more enjoyable, catering to various preferences. For example, Italian sausage adds spiciness, while bacon tastes smoky.

4. Fresh Basil

Homemade Pizza Ingredients List - Fresh Basil as Homemade Pizza Ingredient

Fresh basil transforms homemade pizza with its vibrant flavor and bright green color.

This aromatic herb adds a peppery taste with hints of mint and clove, perfectly complementing the tangy tomato sauce and rich cheese.

It’s best added after baking to preserve its delicate flavor and eye-catching appearance.

Beyond its culinary appeal, basil boasts health benefits and is rich in vitamins A, K, and C and minerals like magnesium and iron.

It also offers anti-inflammatory properties and antioxidants, boosting immune health and improving skin quality.

To incorporate basil into your pizza, try scattering fresh leaves on top after baking to keep them crisp and flavorful.

Alternatively, blend basil into your sauce for a more integrated flavor or drizzle basil-infused olive oil over the finished pizza for an extra layer of fragrance and taste.

Fresh basil ensures your pizza is deliciously complex and visually appealing, whether as a garnish or a key ingredient.

5. Olive Oil

Homemade Pizza Ingredients List - Olive Oil as Homemade Pizza Ingredient

Olive oil is a crucial player in delicious homemade pizza. The best choice is extra virgin. It brings a rich taste and is suitable for you. Picking good olive oil changes your pizza game.

How to Use Olive Oil on Pizza?

Adding EVOO on top improves both the taste and texture of the pizza. Here’s how to do it right:

  • Mix a bit into your pizza dough for a better taste and feel. A recipe loved by many shows how vital quality olive oil is.
  • Make a special sauce for white pizzas with olive oil. Add extras like red pepper flakes or bacon for taste.
  • Before baking, a slight EVOO drizzle makes the crust crispy and not soggy.
  • After baking, a drizzle adds a fresh scent.

Keep garlic and shallots in oil for four days to stay safe. For vegans, olive oil sauce is a great choice. Use these expert tips for a tasty pizza night!

Store infused raw garlic and shallots in oil for four days to prevent bacterial growth. For vegan friends, an olive oil pizza sauce is an excellent vegan option. Use these professional tips and enjoy a restaurant-quality pizza right at home!

6. Ricotta Cheese

Homemade Pizza Ingredients List - Ricotta Cheese as Homemade Pizza Ingredient

Ricotta cheese elevates a white pizza’s flavor profile. Its creamy, slightly sweet taste works great with mozzarella. This creates a rich and indulgent experience.

I use 12 oz of Whole Milk Ricotta and 1 cup of Pecorino Romano for my white pizza. Adding 8 oz of Shredded Mozzarella boosts the cheesiness. This mix creates a delightful creamy topping.

Make the ricotta mixture tasty with 2 tbsp of Minced Garlic, 1/4 tsp of salt, and 1/4 tsp of pepper. These spices enhance the cheese flavor. Baking at 375°F for 10-12 minutes makes it bubbly and delicious.

Naan makes a simple and quick pizza crust. It’s perfect for a homemade gourmet pizza. You can also use a traditional dough or a store-bought one.

The key is to preheat the oven, bake on the bottom rack, and avoid using a rolling pin on the dough.

Whole Milk Ricotta12 oz
Pecorino Romano Cheese1 cup
Shredded Mozzarella8 oz
Minced Garlic2 tbsp
Salt1/4 tsp
Pepper1/4 tsp
Extra Virgin Olive Oil2 tbsp
Dried Basil½ tsp
Grated Garlic Clove1
Dried Chili Flakes¼ to ⅓ tsp

7. Italian Sausage

Homemade Pizza Ingredients List - Italian Sausage as Homemade Pizza Ingredient

Adding Italian sausage brings a hearty, rustic flavor to pizza. It complements other toppings well. To ensure it’s crispy and spread out, cook the sausage before putting it on the pizza.

Cook the sausage until it’s no longer pink. This is key to not having undercooked meat on your pizza later. It makes the sausage tastier and gives it a nice crispy feel.

“The secret to a perfect sausage on pizza is pre-cooking it to lock in flavors and ensure proper doneness.”—Unknown Chef.

Italian sausage goes excellent with a lot of other toppings. Add a tasty combo of red onion, green bell pepper, and mushrooms.

Sprinkle some part-skim mozzarella on top of the sauce before baking. To try something different, use smoked mozzarella for a unique taste.

Have you got leftover Italian sausage pizza? It can stay good in the fridge for three days. Or, if you like planning, you can freeze unbaked pizzas for up to two months. This way, you’re always ready for some homemade pizza.

8. Garlic

Homemade Pizza Ingredients List - Garlic as Homemade Pizza Ingredient

Garlic is not just tasty; it can make a plain pizza unforgettable. You can use it minced, in oil, or roasted. Any way you use it, garlic adds a savory depth to your pizza.

It changes your ordinary pizza into a memorable meal, bursting with flavors.

In white pizzas, garlic often stands in for the usual tomato sauce. This allows for various other creamy sauces, like garlic cream or pesto.

An essential tip for a top-notch garlic pizza is to make the sauce early. This gives the flavors time to mix well.

Here’s a simple guide to making an excellent garlic pizza:

Olive OilBase and Sauce InfusionUse extra virgin or pre-infused garlic olive oil
Fresh GarlicMinced or as whole clovesPrep by steeping in oil for 10 minutes
Mozzarella CheesePrimary CheeseGrate freshly for the best melting
Parmesan CheeseSecondary Cheese for FlavorUse a 2:1 ratio with Mozzarella
Ricotta CheeseOptional White Sauce BaseCombine with olive oil and garlic
HerbsGarnishFresh basil or dried oregano enhances flavors

This simple and versatile recipe makes it an exciting meal option. Pair your garlic pizza with white wine for a special treat.

Always remember the small details matter. Things like storing your sauce can significantly affect the dish’s flavor.

9. Mushrooms

Homemade Pizza Ingredients List - Mushrooms as Homemade Pizza Ingredient

Adding mushrooms to pizzas is a great way to boost the taste. They bring a unique, earthy, and savory flavor. Popular pizzas include baby Bella, shiitake, oyster, portobello, and white button mushrooms.

Using fresh mushrooms is critical for pizza, not canned ones. Fresh ones keep their flavor and texture better when cooked.

Make sure to cook them a bit before topping the pizza. This keeps them juicy and stops them from drying out.

Adding fresh herbs like thyme, oregano, and chives to your mushrooms makes them tastier.

Sauté them with a bit of lemon juice before using them as toppings. This goes great with goat cheese and mozzarella for that stretchy cheese pull.

For the pizza base, go for homemade dough and a white base with olive oil. Bake at 500°F for 5-7 minutes.

This temp will melt the cheese perfectly and brown the crust. Add more herbs and goat cheese after baking for a flavor kick.

10. Balsamic Glaze

Homemade Pizza Ingredients List - Balsamic Glaze as Homemade Pizza Ingredient

A bit of balsamic glaze can give your pizza an unexpected kick. It brings a sweet and tart taste that goes perfectly with cheeses and bread. It makes your pizza taste fancy, encouraging you to play with flavors and textures.

Making this glaze is easy. You need ½ cup of balsamic vinegar and 2 tablespoons of brown sugar. Cook these together for 10 minutes. You’ll end up with a thick sauce that’s great for any pizza.

An Arugula Prosciutto pizza comes alive with a drizzle of balsamic glaze. After adding fresh mozzarella and prosciutto, bake it at 500° F for 10-15 minutes.

Then, top it with arugula and a good swirl of the glaze. It not only looks fantastic but also makes every flavor better.

Need help choosing what to make on pizza night? Let’s compare two tasty balsamic glaze pizza recipes:

IngredientsArugula Prosciutto PizzaBalsamic Glazed Chicken Pizza
BasePizza DoughNaan Bread
Cheese6 oz Fresh Mozzarella12 oz Fresh Mozzarella
Protein4-6 Thin Slices of Prosciutto1 lb Grilled Chicken
VegetablesArugula12 oz Roasted Red Peppers, 1 Red Onion
Glaze1/2 cup Balsamic Glaze4 Tbsp Balsamic Glaze
Baking Time10-15 minutes at 500° F7 minutes at 400ºF
Nutrition InformationCalories: 572, Protein: 24.6gCalories: 793, Protein: 41g

Both pizzas are great. Whether you pick the Arugula Prosciutto or the Balsamic Glazed Chicken, balsamic glaze makes them unique. Using this glaze on pizzas to find your favorite mix is fun!


Creating the perfect homemade pizza is all about balancing flavors. Start with a smooth tomato sauce base. Add rich, stretchy, fresh mozzarella. Next, layer spicy pepperoni and savory Italian sausage for depth.

Sprinkle fresh basil for a burst of freshness. A drizzle of olive oil adds depth. Dot with creamy ricotta for contrast. Sliced garlic and mushrooms bring earthy umami.

Finish with a tangy swirl of balsamic glaze. Each ingredient plays its part beautifully, transforming your pizza into an unforgettable culinary delight. Every bite is a testament to your personal touch and creativity.

Leave a Comment